Reviewing a Solve in Five Minutes

A short review after the puzzle beats an hour of extra play. Here is a four-question script.

Most players review a solve by checking whether they got the answer. That is a pass or fail question and it teaches nothing. A review should answer a different question: where did the solve stop being planned?

A four-question script takes about five minutes. One: what was the plan at rung one, in one sentence? Two: at which rung did that sentence stop being true? Three: was the wrong turn a word problem or a frame problem? Four: what word would have kept the frame alive? The answers go in a notebook, three or four lines in total.

The third question changes behaviour. A word problem is a vocabulary gap and it is fixed by exposure. A frame problem is a planning gap and it is fixed by slowing down at the start. Most players assume all their losses are word problems and drill vocabulary, which is why so many people plateau while feeling like they are improving.

The fourth question turns each review into a small piece of research. Over time it produces a list of words that keep appearing at the moment a plan breaks, and that list is more valuable than a generic vocabulary list because every entry is tied to a real failure. Keep the notebook for a month and the same four or five words will keep repeating. Those are the curriculum. Start guessing on a fresh puzzle after a review like this and the difference is immediate. The daily ladder provides one new test every day, which is exactly the pace this kind of review needs.

Finally, do the review before the next puzzle, not after it. The reasoning from a solved ladder is fragile, and a fresh puzzle displaces most of it within a few minutes. The review is cheap, but only if it happens in the window when the memory is still sharp.